Paul Freshour - The Case of the Former Anheuser Busch Manager Who Murdered Mary Gillispie

Reblogged from：

https://newondp.com/paul-freshour

You may have heard of Paul Freshour, a former Anheuser Busch manager who pleaded not guilty to the murder of Mary Gillispie. Then you may have wondered about his case. In this article, we'll look at his case, how he pleaded not guilty and how he was released on parole in 1994. Regardless, you've probably wondered what made him kill his former coworker.

Paul Freshour was a manager at Anheuser Busch

The two divorced in 1982, when Karen Sue was a prison guard and Paul was working as a manager at Anheuser Busch in Ohio. Freshour had been married to Karen Sue since 1962, and the couple had three children together. The couple separated after Paul was found to have cheated on her. The divorced couple's children remained separated until Karen Sue Freshour filed for divorce and took her children with her. The divorce was finalized when Karen Freshour framed Paul for attempted murder and was given full custody of their children. Karen Freshour, however, was allowed to pursue a relationship with John Sorrick.

During a home cleaning, Karen discovered a letter, addressed to Paul Freshour, an employee of Anheuser-Busch in St. Louis, Missouri. The next day, she checked to see if the letter was still there. It had slid down the toilet. Her son found it and removed it with a coat hanger. The slandering of Freshour's character continues to plague the beer industry.

He pleaded not guilty to insanity

The case was unusual in that a man pleaded not guilty to insanities and was convicted of writing cruel letters while incarcerated. However, the trial court allowed Freshour to appeal the conviction, as he was found guilty of two felonies. Freshour, who was convicted of murdering his wife, was able to plead not guilty to insanity in court. Although he was convicted, Freshour has been in jail for years, and the judge has not ruled out the possibility of a mistake.

Despite the strong evidence against him, Freshour continued to maintain his innocence until the very end. His letters were written to a suspicious woman and the case was built around this woman. The letters began after Freshour's divorce, when his ex-wife requested his typewriter. Paul's sister was not aware of this fact, and thought it strange that her sister would want his possessions during the divorce.

One of the letters was addressed to Anheuser-Busch in St. Louis, Missouri. But the next morning, Karen Sue found it gone. After Paul had pleaded not guilty to insanity, she was forced to pay a decade's jail time for attempted murder. The letters contained some clues as to who the writers were. The letters had a number of letters in them from anonymous sources, including a former prison guard and a bus driver.

He was released on parole in 1994

Freshour served about seven years in prison after committing the crime. He was indicted by a grand jury in March 1983. He was sentenced to seven to 25 years in prison and was given an extra three years for controlling a firearm during the offense. The case remained unsolved until 1994, when he was released on parole. However, Freshour was not able to avoid his fate.

After his conviction, Paul remained behind bars for seven to twenty-four years. However, during his time in prison, he managed to write a blog and made regular public appearances to plead his innocence. However, the letters Paul received while in prison were never published, and Paul hung up his pen and became reclusive. In the early 2000s, his blog was defunct, and his letter-writing career has stalled.

During his time in prison, Freshour was confined to solitary confinement. He was denied access to writing materials and was routinely strip-searched. Freshour's mail was also subject to examination. The prison warden even wrote a letter to his ex-wife Karen, asking her to write him a letter. It was then a matter of time before he was released on parole.

He was killed in 2012

Many people have heard about the case of Paul Freshour, who was murdered in June 2012. He was a successful family man and criminal mastermind who reportedly committed suicide in jail. His estranged wife, Karen Sue, told the Dayton Daily News that her husband became enraged after Mary began to write letters about him. The letters have remained unpublished, but they have served as a poignant reminder of the tragic events that took place in his life.

The letter-writing test was a disputed witness testimony. Mary Freshour was the first person to testify against Paul Freshour, but the sheriff ruled it to be Freshour's handwriting and registered the pistol in his name. While Paul Freshour was released on $50,000 bail, the handwriting evidence has been questioned. A person who copies a letter will try to imitate the style of the author. However, he failed the polygraph test.

Paul Freshour worked at a beer company in Columbus, Ohio. His booby-trap would have been a real challenge, but he had his own gun, and he was armed with it. In fact, the sheriff did not believe the letter writer's version of events, and ruled the case a suicide. In addition to the booby-trap, he had his former brother-in-law, who lived in Grove City, to commit the crime.

Letters sent from prison match his handwriting

In late February 1983, Mary Freshour found a sealed envelope with letters from Paul Freshour inside. The letterhead was in Paul's handwriting, and the police thought the letters were from him. They asked Paul to take a handwriting test to compare them to the letters he had written from prison. Although Paul had never attempted to kill anyone, he was charged with attempted murder and was put on $50,000 bail.

The letters were mailed to Karen, a fellow bus driver, and they were dated in the same month. Karen said Paul was a nice guy who was always nice, but quickly became angry if someone disagreed with him. In court, Karen Sue described Paul Freshour as someone who was close to her, like a brother or sister. Paul was convicted of attempted murder based on circumstantial evidence, and the handwriting on the letters matched the letters Paul had sent from prison.

The letterhead of the letters, written by Paul, was found in the same handwriting. Paul's handwriting matches the letterhead's because he wrote the letters himself. However, the letterheads were a different color than the letters Paul sent to Mary. There is no way that Paul was writing in a different handwriting than the letters he received from Mary Gillispie.

Letters to David Longberry

The most compelling theory that ties together all of the pieces is the theory that David Longberry started out harassing Paul Freshour. This theory was originally proposed by Mary Gillispie, who suspected Longberry of being the harasser. In his letters, David made passes at Mary, and she rejected his advances. Karen, however, took over the harassing campaign after Paul was accused of having a romantic interest in a superintendent.

The letters were discovered in a file and seized by the FBI, but Freshour denied writing them. Regardless of the reason, the letters helped cement this case as one of the most puzzling true crime mysteries of all time. Many of those involved are dead, and Freshour himself was released on parole in 1994 after serving ten years. Freshour maintained his innocence until his death in 2012.

Although Paul Freshour was the owner of a gun, he denied the charges, and was not involved in setting the booby trap. The sheriff's office identified the gun used in the booby trap as Freshour's. Freshour was arrested and was released on $50,000 bond. He later checked into Riverside Hospital Mental Health Center. In addition to Paul Freshour's trial, the court found out that he bought the gun from a co-worker. However, he had taken the day off of work on the day of the booby trap. And Paul Freshour's handwriting matched the 103 letters sent to David Longberry.

Letters to Mary Gillispie match his handwriting

It is not clear who wrote the letter to Mary Gillispie, but it's likely a woman who shared the superintendent's initials. It is likely a woman who felt wronged by Paul, and wanted to expose her as a cheater. It is unknown if the letter writer was Paul Freshour or a friend. Several witnesses have testified that they know both people, including Mary.

Freshour's letters were discovered in a letter he sent to a woman in Circleville in 1974. The letters were dated September 18, 1976. The woman was the wife of an Ohio entrepreneur. In the letter, Freshour claims that he was jealous of her success and that she would have given him a higher pay. Freshour denies the accusations, saying the letters were not his.

After Paul was released from prison, he stopped writing letters to Mary. Then, the letter writer's handwriting began matching the letters. The handwriting expert used to study Paul's handwriting found similarity to hers. However, the letter writer's fingerprints were also found on the letters. While Paul never faced any criminal charges for the letters, he died of a heart attack on June 28, 2012.